Once again, no not the anime. Although I should check out the anime and make a comparison against this…
The new Romance of the Three Kingdoms live-action TV series produced by mainland China began airing just a few days ago on May 2, 2010. Contrary to my original expectations, this series was not actually produced by CCTV, which might be the fundamental cause on why I haven’t enjoyed it as much as the original 1994 adaptation.
As they had advertised, the new series began with Cao Cao’s attempt to assassinate Dong Zhuo, instead of starting at the beginning of the original novels with the Peach Garden Oath (which was only displayed with a short scene). This meant that the story was cut down significantly to only its most interesting parts. However, Director Gao Xixi also saw it fit to change numerous other minor aspects of the storyline, ranging from Liu Bei’s first warlord benefactor to speeding up the development of his relationship with Cao Cao. It seems he wants to focus the development on the main cast as much as possible, even at the expense of minor logical consistencies. This is a bit sad since one of ROTK’s greatest aspects is how well it managed to sculpt its huge cast of characters.
The significantly higher budget invested is evident in the series. The stage setting, the costumes, and especially the battle sequences they’ve shown thus far are all noticeably better than before. The battlefield scenes have been a bit short and frantic, although that’s expected since there hasn’t been a notable field engagement yet. But to make up for it, the generals’ fight scenes have been thrilling and well-choreographed, especially the Lu-Guan-Zhang versus Lu Bu fight in episode 5. The camera angles do need some work though, as they’re often too close and change too quickly.
My main complaint with the new series lay with the actors and their character portrayal. From the sharp voice Zhang Fei has which makes him sound like some classic villainous Asian official, to Liu Bei who shows barely any human emotions even though he’s meant to be a very expressive person, to the young and handsome Lu Bu who lacks the passion and fury his character is meant to contain, to Cao Cao who always sound like he’s short on breath… not to mention, none of the characters thus far has the sheer presence and aura of authority they should have (and they did in the 1994 adaptation). Their speeches simply lack the backing of that natural tone of a leader and doesn’t leave much impression on the listener. The poor acting was made worse by the bland audio soundtrack, with the background music not only being simplistic, but they’re also extremely cheesy and poorly integrated, sticking out like a sore thumb as if this was some average Hong Kong martial arts movie.
After how much I’d been anticipating this, it’s actually been a bit of a downer. Hopefully it’s just me still being biased towards the 1994 series and that I’ll like this better with some time…
More info:
Release Date: 2 May 2010 (China)
Country: China
Box office: Budget: CNY 150,000,000 (estimated)
Mediafire Movies - Best sharing and downloading. Copyright © 2010 - 2012. System loaded in 0.1563 seconds
